Recent Reviews on Google



The following reviews were kindly sent by customers to our website.

Lobster Pier has been a favorite of mine for 30+ years. The service is impeccable,the staff are friendly, and Alan will make sure your dinner is what you expected ! I just love the Seafood Posollipo,and someday i may order something different , but i doubt…it’s the best !

Johnny Quaranta

Goshen, NY

I had my mother’s 85 birthday party in November. My mom was treated like a queen. The service was spectacular, food delicious and hostess gracious. They set up our table in the more private room and it was just beautiful. My mother said I could not have chosen a better place for her birthday. Thank you for all you do for the community to make our special occasions Rock!!!

Tina Gordon

Goshen, NY

AWESOME!!!!! No need to say more. Go experience it for yourself. You WILL NOT be dissappointed.


Chester, NY

I had The Penne Pasta with Sauteed Chicken Breast, Broccoli, Sun-dried Tomatoes and Garlic Herb Sauce. What I had was nothing short of “Amazing” My wife had The Jumbo Fried Shrimp and was also nothing short of “Amazing” And the Seafood Bar was nothing short of “Amazing” too. (FIVE ***** STARS)
Sincerely, Rick Ferrusi

Rick and Lisa Ferrusi

Middletown N.Y.

I had went for My mothers bday, and let me say from the moment we entered it was a welcoming environment! Everyone was so friendly made you feel welcomed! Food was great and the two salad bars are amazing lots of food all you can eat! Only complaint is the sea food bar not much of the best choices and the mussels had rocks inside! Didn’t like it much! I had the stuff filet with crab and shrimp and only had two shrimps inside and lots of stuffing! Was happy about that! Otherwise Everything else was tasty n the desert was amazing! Heading over again with a crowd! Great place.



Alice and I were in New York over the weekend. My cousin took us out to dinner at The Lobster Pier in Chester, NY. Being from New England, I didn’t think that i would be impressed by a land locked NY seafood restaurant. Boy was I wrong ! I had a plate of raw “Little Neck” clams that were outstanding ! Highly recommend this place to my friends in Orange county, NY.

David Hattenbrun III

Kensington, New Hampshire

This little place in Chester NY delivers big in taste and quality. It’s right next to the Holiday Inn and after a long drive from the city it’s a walk from the Inn. The menu is all about fish, steak and pasta. However the salad bar is over the top!

Cal Gordon

Rhododendron, Oregon

I love this place! The food is very fresh and very good. My favorite is the Lobster Fra Diablo, which I always get on my birthday in July. A++

Steven Sanchez

Wappinger's Falls, NY

I have been there twice and plan on going back. They have the best crab cakes I have ever had! I highly recommend them. The trout is also excellent.

Eileen Manning

Mt Hope, NY

This is a well run local establishment with fresh good seafood and excellent aged steaks. Generous portions, seafood appetizer and salad bar. Great friendly service, owner hands on, a really welcoming atmosphere.

Alex C

Lexington, Kentucky, United States

The minute you walk through the door you are greeted A+. Wait staff very good. And the food is hot and delicious. We keep coming back for more.

Rosanna Poggiogalle

Greenwood Lake, NY


We value customer feedback and would love to hear about your experience at Lobster Pier! Please fill out this form and let us know how we did!
  • Tell us where you are from.
  • Tell us about your experience at Lobster Pier.